“Freedom of Speech, Modern Western Concept & Religious Concepts” By F. Sheikh

 First Amendment of USA Constitution, ratified in 1791, represents the best of Modern Western concepts of freedom of speech, which states;

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

Only Government entities are prohibited from restricting freedom of speech, and it does not apply to private entities such as businesses or education institutes. Many colleges practice freedom of speech to encourage free thought and expression but they could place restrictions if they chose to do so.

The US Supreme Court over the years elaborated and defined, in its case-laws what rights are protected under freedom of speech and what is prohibited speech. The protected rights include, but are not limited to:

Not to speak (specifically, the right not to salute the flag).

Students wear black armbands to school to protest a war.

To use certain offensive words and phrases to convey political messages.

To contribute money (under certain circumstances) to political campaigns.

To engage in symbolic speech, (e.g., burning the flag in protest).

Freedom of speech does not Protect;

Hate and violent Speech. In Brandenburg v Ohio in 1939 Supreme Court ruled that hateful and violent speech that incites and poses imminent danger of violence and lawlessness is not protected speech.

Obscene Speech; Obscene speech is not protected. In 1973 Miller v California

Chief Justice Warrenburger outlined “Miller Test” to define the obscene speech. The jury must determine whether an average person, applying contemporary community standards, finds the work as whole exhibits following all three elements.

  • appeals to the prurient interest;
  • depicts or describes, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the applicable state law; and
  • lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value.

Defamation Speech;Defamation speech is not protected. However, courts mostly err on the side of freedom of speech than restrict it to promote expression of free thoughts. It is especially important to hold public officials accountable and face scrutiny of their work by public and press without fear of defamation lawsuits which may have chilling effect on freedom of speech.

As public officials, politicians, and celebrities hold special positions in public’s eyes, hence they are fair subjects of discussion and analysis. Therefore, in defamation lawsuits they face higher standard of burden of proof as compared to ordinary citizens. They must prove that defamation speech caused them harm, it was false, and was done with malice intent or knowingly disregarded the truth. Malice is hard to prove. The ordinary citizen must prove only the harm done by defamation speech and it was false. It does not require malice intent.

 Before the above modern western concept of freedom of speech, along with separation of State and church, emerged during Enlightenment period of 17th and 18th centuries, it was mostly religious doctrine that influenced boundaries of freedom of speech.

Freedom of Speech in Islam, Christianity, and Judaism

Islam, Christianity, and Judaism all command to speak the truth, speak against injustice and wrongdoing, and engage in responsible speech.

 Quran and Hadith; A-Quran 4:148 ; Speaking Against Injustice;

لَا يُحِبُّ اللَّهُ الْجَهْرَ بِالسُّوءِ مِنَ الْقَوْلِ إِلَّا مَن ظُلِمَ ۚ وَكَانَ اللَّهُ سَمِيعًا عَلِيمًا

“Allah does not like the public mention of evil except by one who has been wronged. And Allah is Hearing and Knowing.”

The verse discourages speaking evil of others except those who have been wronged. They can talk about the wrong done to them in public by government officials, powerful individuals, or employers.

B-Quran 3:104 Calling people toward what is right.

وَلْتَكُن مِّنكُمْ أُمَّةٌ يَدْعُونَ إِلَى الْخَيْرِ وَيَأْمُرُونَ بِالْمَعْرُوفِ وَيَنْهَوْنَ عَنِ الْمُنكَرِ ۚ وَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْمُفْلِحُونَ

“And let there be among you a community inviting to all that is good, uniting what is right and forbidding what is wrong. And it is they who are successful.”

This verse takes us into political arena where you are commanded to call on the community to stand for what is right and speak against what is wrong such as corruption, injustice, social ills, and reforms in society.

C; Sunan Abi Dawud — Hadith 4344 ;أَفْضَلُ الْجِهَادِ كَلِمَةُ عَدْلٍ عِنْدَ سُلْطَانٍ جَائِرٍ

 “The best jihad is a word of justice spoken before an oppressive ruler.”

D-Qur’an 39:18 — Listen to different statements and follow the best

Arabic:الَّذِينَ يَسْتَمِعُونَ الْقَوْلَ فَيَتَّبِعُونَ أَحْسَنَهُ

“Those who listen to what is said and follow the best of it.”

Bible

“And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.”John 8:32, King James Version

“We ought to obey God rather than men.”  Acts 5:29, King James Version

This verse advocates not to follow the orders of the ruler or leader if the orders are against the commands of God.

“Open thy mouth, judge righteously, and plead the cause of the poor and needy-Proverbs 31:8–9

Judaism

Torah, Leviticus 19:16: “You shall not go up and down as a talebearer among your people; neither shalt thou stand idly by the blood of thy neighbor: I am the LORD.” This verse prohibits idle talk and back biting and stands against injustice.

Exodus 23:1:“Thou shalt not raise a false report: put not thine hand with the wicked to be an unrighteous witness.”

“Open thy mouth, judge righteously, and plead the cause of the poor and needy. Proverbs 31:8–9,

All three religions contain teachings which command to speak the truth, confront wrongdoing, speak against injustice, and exercise responsible speech. They also contain ethical restrictions on some forms of expressions. The strongest restrictions are against speaking ill of God and his prophets (blasphemy). Bible and Torah explicitly prescribes death sentence for such sins (Leviticus 24:16 in both Torah and Bible). Quran condemns, admonishes, and warns of punishment in Hereafter for such sins, but does not prescribe worldly death sentence and advises followers to just leave such gatherings where such talk is taking place. (Quran 33:57, 6:68, 4:140). However, some Hadiths recommend capital punishment ( Al-Bukhari 4037).

In the West, the transformation from religious doctrine to modern concept of freedom of speech started with the Protestant Reformation movement led by Martin Luther in the 16th century which led to the weakening of political power of Catholic Church. A new era of Enlightenment unfolded in the 17th and 18th century. During this period important thinkers like John Locke, Voltaire, Baruch Spinoza and others argued against Church’s meddling in politics and advocated civil liberties, individuals’ rights, freedom of expression, and separation of State and Church. This led to the separation of State and Church and modern concept of freedom of speech in the West.

In Muslim world, semi-separation of religion and state started in early Islamic period, especially during Abbasid period, where Islamic Scholars would independently issue fatwas which would influence the political rulers but many times political rulers will use the Islamic Scholars, some of them on Government payroll, to issue fatwa to justify and facilitate their own rule.  

In the West, Separation of State and Church does not mean that religion has no influence on modern concept of freedom of speech. Teachings of all three major religions, Islam, Christianity, and Judaism, influenced the formulation of the founding underpinnings of freedom of speech to freely speak against injustice, corruption, and prohibit violent speech, defamation speech, and obscene speech.  

John Locke famously said, “All individuals are born with inalienable rights to life, liberty, and property.”

Religious teachings were on Thomas Jefferson’s mind when he drafted the American Declaration of Independence, changing Locke’s original phrasing to the memorable line: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

FAYYAZ SHEIKH

( Prepared in collaboration with AI research)